Even though the original post is from 2008, Freelancing Doesn't Mean Free by Rebecca Stigall was published on Creative Freelancing just yesterday. The site doesn't allow comments, so I am commenting here.
I understand the need for freelancers to protect their livelihood. Yet, I found several claims in the above article that require a closer look.
The writer complains that the low copywriting fees you can get by offshoring are not enough to sustain an American copywriter. That's true, of course. From the client's viewpoint, however, the question is: If I can get the same quality at a lower price, why should I want to pay more just to help keep up someone's lifestyle?
Isn't this just the reason why companies are outsourcing production, for example?
The article attempts to justify non-offshoring by saying "even if a buyer's financial needs are met through outsourcing, their project needs rarely are"
. It would be interesting to know what kind of research is behind "rarely". If companies as a rule did not get the benefits they expect from offshoring, it would be really strange that offshoring is as popular as it is today.
Even stranger is the claim that "ya
[sic] just can't write effectively to an American audience if your first language isn't English"
It's not a question of English being your first, second or umpteenth language. It's a question of having a good command of the language.
True, if you're writing B2C copy, colloquial expressions and a grassroots-level knowledge of American culture and sub-cultures may be important. In contrast, if you're writing about industrial gears, automation systems, banking solutions, wastewater treatment or power supply systems, cultural differences are less important.
If the copy achieves the Most Wanted Response determined for the marketing piece and is grammatically correct, why would it be important whether it is "made in America" or elsewhere? Besides, a professional from the outside may have a fresher look and new ideas.
If you're a business looking to lower the cost of producing your marketing materials, you might want to take a look at a couple of blog posts touching on this topic: How to find the ideal freelance business-to-business copywriter
and How to handle your advertising in-house without the downside
Business is global. So are business services. Widen your perspectiveâ€”you may get surprising benefits.